R3 Worldwide have complied a list of the past year’s best integrated campaigns from up to 40 different brands worldwide. Here’s what R3 has to say about the process of their complied findings;
“In determining 40 of the best integrated approaches of the last year, we undertook a Call for Entries – reaching out to more than 50 of the world’s best marketers and their agencies. To be fair and transparent, this process was totally free, and entrants could submit as many as they wanted.
We were overwhelmed with the response we received – more than 200 entries from six continents, involving thousands of individual agency relationships – Integration is clearly an important topic.”
There’s four main categories R3 look at when it comes to deciding who makes the cut;
1) ‘Proven on top brands’
2) ‘Proven on creativity’
3) ‘Proven on process’
4) ‘Proven on results’
So based on these categories, how do R3 narrow down the best of the best? When it comes to what defines integration, they look for the following;
1. Multiple Best in Class Agencies
In this model, the marketer leads integration – choosing the best possible creative, media, digital, PR and event agencies regardless of their parents – and then has the task to put them together. This is by far the most common method we see – the “best of breed” and it occurred in 38% of cases in our analysis. The challenge with it, is that it puts a lot of onus back on the marketer – companies such as Coca-Cola have now set up IMC teams just to “herd all the cats”.
2. Lead Agency Model
Done to its full extent, as P&G has tried over the years with its “Brand Agency Leader” model , this structure puts the pressure back to the lead agency to drive integration. We saw this model in 25% of cases, and what was more interesting was to read the examples where someone other than a creative agency was taking the lead (32% of occasions) – the world did not end, and the campaign was still executed brilliantly. Expect to see more of this model in the future.
3. Sibling Agency Model
When the Holding Company was “invented” , this was no doubt the integration model in everyone’s mind. That it only occurred in 20% of the cases of the final 40 suggests it may yet to be seen as the optimal model for the future. In this structure, there’s a simplicity in the working process, but a potential lack of flexibility for the marketer when things go wrong. No one is ready to throw the baby out with the bathwater.
4. Holding Company Custom Agency
Much loved by Apple. Envied by others. Tried by Dell in the past. Working well for Ford, Colgate and others, this is essentially about a holding company pooling resources into a dedicated 100% team within a holding group. This can only work well for clients with scale, but of course, has its own challenges with attracting the best creative talent and breakthrough thinking.
5. Free Agent
Here in this era of crowdsourcing and social, will this be a new model whose time is to come? We look at Sony, with its nine roster agencies fighting on a project by project basis. This has also been an approach tried by Intel in the past. What the marketer gains in total flexibility of creative resources , it surely loses in terms of strategic governance and contribution. Unilever and JWT just celebrated 115 years together – how would both companies be performing if it was only 115 days?
6. One Stop Shop
A relic of the Mad Men days, but still the common approach in Japan, Korea and Brazil, along with smaller marketers who simply can’t afford multiple agencies. For every person who dreams of creative and media agencies merging back again , there must surely be two who recognize the giant strides in media sophistication that has occurred with them apart. While we saw this in 10% of our relationships. We wonder in five years time if this will be the case.
What they discovered through these categories and guidelines is quite fascinating. For example, curating an idea is just as important as creating it and practice makes perfect when it comes to dedicated integration. Also the fact that big brands like Coca Cola, Ikea, Nestle & Samsung have raised their game in the world in integrated campaigning reinforces why these brands on others have made the list. Who else is on that list you say? Check out the list below. You can also view all the best integrated campaigns on R3’s site here.
Beats by Dr Dre
Coca-Cola (Share a Lyric)
Head & Shoulders
Hindustan Unilever India
IDLC Finance Limited
Mawbima (published by Ceylon Newspapers)
Nurve (Nissan United Real-Time Vision for Engagement)
Samsung Galaxy 11
Ubisoft (Assassin’s Creed)
Visa (Sochi Olympics)
Warner Brothers (Lego Movie)